Fallout 3 Graphic Poll

Haris · Post by **Haris** » Sun Jan 30, 2005 10:52 pm

After playing Anarchy online and seing how good they made Newland desert look and how they made it feel exactly like fallout but in 3d third person not isometric. It feels like being inside fallout and you can look up in the sky. I would rather see fallout 3 being made like that. Only important thing would be turnbased combat.

Post by **Retlaw83** » Sun Jan 30, 2005 11:09 pm

Newland desert looks just about like any other desert in existence.

You want post-apocalyptic, go out to Wartorn Valley and look at walled Old Athen in the distance.

Someguy353 · Post by **Someguy353** » Wed Feb 09, 2005 1:26 pm

What about 2d mix 3d like commandos 2. Prerendered graphic aren't too bad when they are done well.

Post by **Retlaw83** » Wed Feb 09, 2005 2:37 pm

FoT had 2D backgrounds with pre-rendered 3D characters.

Not having played Commandos 2, are you talking about actual 3D models on 2D terrain - such as in the original Sims - or the way FoT did things?

Kahgan · Post by **Kahgan** » Wed Feb 09, 2005 7:01 pm

I'm pretty sure the walls, scenery and items in fallout were rendered 3d models too, you'd need extreme skills and even more extreme patience tohanddraw all those walls, items and scenery...

Kashluk · Post by **Kashluk** » Wed Feb 09, 2005 9:53 pm

And so, FOT was completely 2D.

Fallout 1, 2 and Tactics have been all two-dimensional. Fo:BoS is an exception, but it doesn't count, now does it?

I suggest you go with 3D. When you're trying to make a huge game, it's more efficient anyway. 2D is just too much of a fuzz after you reach a certain level, 3D is more practical and *when used right* provides nearly as fine results.

Someguy353 · Post by **Someguy353** » Thu Feb 10, 2005 11:50 am

If Fallout 3 is 3D I hope for something like NWN. But one thing I don't like 3D games is the heavy demand on the system spec. I want Fallout 3 to look good and play good on older systems, here what commandos 2 is like:
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/screen4.jpg
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/screen2.jpg
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/pc4.jpg

It has 2d high very detail render with zoom and 4 way rotation. It's 3d when your inside buildings. All the charactors are rendered in full 3d! And it only requires a minimum of PII-300 64 MB RAM 16MB graphic RAM to run it, I don't see why FALLOUT 3 can't be like that.

Kashluk · Post by **Kashluk** » Thu Feb 10, 2005 2:25 pm

But think about how many different maps commandos had.

Yeah, get it now?

Someguy353 · Post by **Someguy353** » Thu Feb 10, 2005 3:42 pm

Commandos 2 have 22 maps and some of them are really huge. Loading time is very short too.

Briosafreak · Post by **Briosafreak** » Thu Feb 10, 2005 3:56 pm

Commandos2 is fully 2d.

Post by **Retlaw83** » Thu Feb 10, 2005 4:28 pm

Someguy353 wrote:If Fallout 3 is 3D I hope for something like NWN. But one thing I don't like 3D games is the heavy demand on the system spec. I want Fallout 3 to look good and play good on older systems, here what commandos 2 is like:
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/screen4.jpg
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/screen2.jpg
http://commandos2.euweb.cz/obrazky/pc4.jpg

It has 2d high very detail render with zoom and 4 way rotation. It's 3d when your inside buildings. All the charactors are rendered in full 3d! And it only requires a minimum of PII-300 64 MB RAM 16MB graphic RAM to run it, I don't see why FALLOUT 3 can't be like that.

Fallout 3 can't be like that because it will be a market competitive title released probably in 2007. By then, "low-end" systems will be ones with 256mb of RAM.

While Fallout fans would buy a game with a 2D engine if it had the same depth as the first games, other people wouldn't. What are the combined sales of Fallout, Fallout 2 and Tactics? Somewhere around a million copies worldwide? In this day and age, those are laughable sales figures, and Bethesda has no reason to spend millions catering to a few hundred thousand people like some fucking charity when they can make real money by creating a game with mass appeal.

Fallout 3 will probably be top-down, because top-down games do just as well as first person ones. But it won't be turn-based - not because there isn't a market for it (Civilization 3 and the strategic level of the Total War series, anyone?) but because publishers and developers don't <i>think</i> there's a market for it.

And also, in the end, it'll be more about gang warfare and hookers instead of delicate town-by-town balance of power issues because the former sells and most RPG players (read Diablo and Morrowind fans) these days couldn't give a flying Siamese fuck about the latter.

mowgleh · Post by **mowgleh** » Fri Feb 11, 2005 10:18 pm

I agree with retlaw. While I would like fo3 to look like commandos2, I dont see it happening either :-/

But I still think theres a real posibility it could be turn based, or maybe im just wishing.

Either way as long as the story line does blow ass, ill be happy, I geuss..

Mad Max · Post by **Mad Max** » Fri Mar 04, 2005 8:27 pm

So really Fo:3 is going to be totally fucked, and now hear me through, it might have same kind of plot, same history, and same item/weapons or something, but in the way of the classic Isometric, third person, and turned based are totally going to be thrown out the door, "thats shit!!" that really upsets me, It upsets me enough where I will not be buying Fallout 3 till like 3 weeks after its release because I will have to ponder over reviews and watch previews to make the right desicion. I really hope someone see it alittle my way because if I am the only one then there is no hope.

Deadeye Dragoon · Post by **Deadeye Dragoon** » Mon Mar 07, 2005 1:11 am

One of the "good" things about the lengthy time between Fallout 2 and 3 is the vast improvement in 3D graphics. Six years ago 2D was the clear winnar in art quality, by far, but 3D has slowly closed the gap. I wouldn't like the 3D graphics for Fallout that are found in Morrowind, too muddied for a gritty Fallout world, but hopefully the quality of Fallout: Tactics (or FO1 and 2 if you prefer) would be captured by a 3D engine of today.

So, I don't really care as long as the graphics are good. I remember four years ago I detested the idea of a 3D Fallout 3, but things have changed a lot since then.

Mr. Teatime · Post by **Mr. Teatime** » Mon Mar 07, 2005 1:17 am

Fallout 3 is going to be 3D, there's no doubt about that. It's how it's implemented that's important. I think the way Van Buren was headed in terms of graphics was great. The characters looked like the sprites of the originals, except they were 3D.

Kahgan · Post by **Kahgan** » Mon Mar 07, 2005 6:33 pm

I did not like the look of Van Buren... especially the vault didn't appeal to me...and the characters looked...wierd...hard to say what was wrong with them, but they certantly weren't good...at least not to me...

Mad Max · Post by **Mad Max** » Fri Mar 25, 2005 5:04 am

There has been talk around the camera thing who wants the camera to be locked behind him or be totally adjustable like in Silent Storm camera.
In my words both work

Someguy353 · Post by **Someguy353** » Sat Mar 26, 2005 3:07 pm

I'm hoping it would have nice graphics, but also works will on low spec machines, such as laptops.....

Few games that seems to do that well:

Commandos 2 and 3
NOX
Divity Divine

hum... that all I can think off right now

Kurt · Post by **Kurt** » Sat Mar 26, 2005 3:32 pm

Mad Max wrote:I'd like to see fallout 3 with like the original graphics it gave it an edge and low computer specs because who want to overclock just to play a complex text and graphic game

Me to but how Fallout 3 will look than Hal life 2 etc...
By the way I'm yearning for 2D graphiks from fallout 1&2...

Cuthbert Allgood · Post by **Cuthbert Allgood** » Tue May 03, 2005 4:13 am

Yeah but making a game with "low end specs" like fallout 1 would not cost very much at all. infact if i had the time and a few more fallout editors i could make a new fallout game myself<with maybe a little help>

Duck and Cover

Fallout 3 Graphic Poll

Who Wants Fallout 3 To have Graphics Like FO1&2 or have it like FOT

Re: Fallout 3 Graphic Poll